Full Refutation of the Muslim Response to the Islamic Dilemma
The Islamic Dilemma remains deadly to Islam, because:
π 1. The Qur'an clearly confirms the scriptures available at Muhammad's time (the Bible).
π 2. The Qur'an never says the Bible was corrupted before Muhammad.
π 3. Muslims have no proof the Bible was changed before Muhammad — in fact, the Qur'an appeals to the Bible as it existed then. π 4. Therefore, either the Qur'an is wrong, or the Bible is reliable — either way, Islam falls.
Let’s now answer each point in the Muslim’s post specifically:
1. "The Qur'an only refers to the original revelations, not today's Bible."
Wrong.
The Qur'an speaks of the Torah and Gospel present in Muhammad’s time — and tells Jews and Christians to judge by what they have.
Proof:
Surah 5:43 — "But how is it that they come to you for judgment while they have the Torah, in which is the judgment of Allah?"
Surah 5:47 — "Let the people of the Gospel judge by what Allah has revealed therein."
"Have" = present tense — they already possessed it.
Allah says the Torah and Gospel still contain His judgment.
If it was corrupted, why would Allah tell them to judge by it?
π The Qur'an confirms the Bible as it existed in Muhammad's day, not some lost "original."
2. "Quran 2:75 says they 'distorted' the Words — so the Bible was corrupted."
Wrong again.
The Qur'an speaks of distorting (ΨͺΨΨ±ΩΩ tahrif) — but distortion is not the same as textual corruption.
"Tahrif" means misinterpretation, twisting meanings — not changing the text.
Nowhere does the Qur'an say the actual Bible text was re-written or lost.
Even Muslim scholars like Ibn Taymiyyah admitted that "tahrif" is often verbal distortion — twisting meanings, not physical corruption.
Proof from Qur'an:
Surah 2:79 — "Woe to those who write the Book with their hands and say, 'This is from Allah.'"
Even here — it's condemning some people making fake writings, not saying the entire Torah or Gospel is corrupted.
π Conclusion: The Qur'an never teaches that the Torah and Gospel were fully corrupted. It presumes their reliability.
3. "The Prophet didn't affirm the Bible because the hadith is weak."
Doesn't matter.
Even without the hadith, the Qur'an itself commands Christians and Jews to refer to their scriptures.
More devastating proof:
Surah 10:94 — "If you are in doubt about what We have revealed to you, ask those who read the Scripture before you."
Muhammad is told to consult the People of the Book (Jews and Christians).
Why ask them if their books are corrupted?
If the Bible was corrupted, Allah would warn against it — but He does the opposite.
π The Qur'an assumes the Bible's authority during Muhammad’s lifetime.
4. "Christians have contradictions and corruptions in the Bible."
Even if that were true, it doesn’t help Islam.
Because:
The Qur'an says the Torah and Gospel were revelations from Allah.
The Qur'an affirms their authority.
If the Bible is corrupted, then the Qur'an is wrong for confirming it.
That’s the Islamic Dilemma:
| Possibility | Result |
|---|---|
| The Bible is trustworthy | Then Christianity is true, not Islam. |
| The Bible is corrupt | Then the Qur'an is false for confirming it. |
π Either way, Islam falls.
Short Summary Bomb π£
The Qur'an confirms the Bible present at Muhammad’s time (Surah 5:43, 5:47, 10:94).
It never says the Bible was corrupted before Muhammad.
"Tahrif" is twisting meanings, not rewriting scripture.
If the Bible is corrupted, the Qur'an is wrong.
If the Bible is true, Christianity wins.
Islam cannot survive the Islamic Dilemma.
Islam Cannot Escape the Islamic Dilemma π₯
The "Islamic Dilemma" destroys Islam in one clean shot:
| Option | Result |
|---|---|
| Bible is preserved | Christianity is true — Islam is false. |
| Bible is corrupted | Qur'an is wrong for confirming it — Islam is false. |
There’s no third option. Islam dies either way.
Muslims' Excuse:
"The Qur'an only confirms the original Torah and Gospel, not the Bible today!"
Wrong.
π Surah 5:43 — "They have the Torah..."
π Surah 5:47 — "Let the People of the Gospel judge by what Allah revealed therein."
The Qur'an talks about the Torah and Gospel Christians and Jews HAD in Muhammad’s day — not some "lost" original!
If the Bible was corrupted, why would Allah command Christians to judge by it?
If it was corrupted, why would Allah tell Muhammad to ask the "People of the Book" if he doubted (Surah 10:94)?
Allah himself confirms the Bible.
Muslim dodge:
"But the Bible has contradictions!"
π Stop.
If the Bible is corrupted, then your Qur'an is wrong for trusting it.
If the Bible is true, then Islam is wrong for denying it.
You can't have it both ways.
Islam is trapped.
Either the Bible is true → Islam is false.
Or the Bible is false → Islam is false.
Islam loses. Always.
No comments:
Post a Comment