❗If Abraham, Moses, and Jesus Were Muslims — Why Does Nothing They Taught Look Like Islam?
🧭 Introduction: The Core Islamic Claim
Islam teaches that every true prophet — from Adam to Muhammad — was a Muslim, preaching the same religion. According to the Qur’an:
“Indeed, the religion in the sight of Allah is Islam.” — Surah 3:19
So when Muslims say Abraham, Moses, and Jesus were “Muslims,” they don’t just mean “submitted to God” in a generic way. They mean these men taught the core tenets of Islamic monotheism (tawhid), Islamic law (Sharia), Islamic rituals (salat, zakat, fasting), and belief in Muhammad as the final prophet.
But here’s the problem:
There is zero historical, scriptural, or archaeological evidence that any of them taught anything resembling Islam.
📜 Part 1: What Did Abraham Actually Teach?
Islamic Claim:
Abraham built the Kaaba with Ishmael (Surah 2:125–127).
He faced Mecca, performed Hajj, and submitted to the Islamic understanding of Allah.
He was neither Jew nor Christian, but a "Muslim" (Surah 3:67).
Reality Check — According to the Torah:
Abraham worshipped Yahweh, not “Allah.”
He had no connection to Mecca — a city that didn’t even exist in his lifetime.
He built altars in Canaan, not a cube shrine in Arabia.
His covenant was passed to Isaac, not Ishmael (Genesis 17:19–21).
He instituted circumcision as a sign of the covenant, not salah or zakat.
There is not a single Islamic practice or doctrine mentioned in the account of Abraham. No Mecca, no Kaaba, no salat, no zakat, no Sharia.
📌 Key Problem:
Why would a “Muslim prophet” teach zero Islamic rituals and establish a non-Islamic covenant with a different people?
📜 Part 2: What Did Moses Actually Teach?
Islamic Claim:
Moses was a prophet of Islam (Surah 2:87).
He delivered Allah’s law, which was later corrupted.
His true religion was Islam, and his miracles supported tawhid.
Reality Check — According to the Torah:
Moses received the Ten Commandments from Yahweh, not Allah.
He established a full Jewish religious system: priesthood, sacrifices, tabernacle, festivals (Leviticus).
He enforced Sabbath laws — something Islam ignores.
He predicted another prophet like himself from among Israel (Deut. 18:18) — not an Arab in Mecca.
None of Islam’s central teachings — Mecca, Muhammad, Quran, salat, fasting, zakat — are found anywhere in Moses’ actual message.
📌 Key Problem:
If Moses was a Muslim prophet, why does the law he gave look entirely Jewish and explicitly reject all things Islamic?
📜 Part 3: What Did Jesus Actually Teach?
Islamic Claim:
Jesus was a Muslim who preached tawhid.
He was a prophet, not divine.
He did not die or rise from the dead.
He foretold the coming of Muhammad (Surah 61:6).
Reality Check — According to the New Testament and earliest Christian sources:
Jesus repeatedly calls God His “Father” — a concept Islam considers blasphemy (John 17:1–3).
He claimed to be one with the Father (John 10:30), and the “I AM” (John 8:58).
He accepted worship (Matthew 14:33), forgave sins (Mark 2:5), and predicted His death and resurrection (Mark 8:31).
His message was centered on the Kingdom of God, not Islamic law.
He never mentioned Muhammad, Mecca, the Quran, or Islamic rituals.
In fact, the earliest Christians worshipped Jesus as Lord from the very beginning — centuries before Islam existed.
📌 Key Problem:
If Jesus was a Muslim, why does every piece of historical and textual evidence — including the Gospels, Paul’s letters, early church writings, and Roman records — say otherwise?
🧠 Part 4: The Historical Silence of Islam Before the 7th Century
If Islam is the original religion of all prophets:
Why is there no trace of it in ancient Judaism or Christianity?
Why do no pre-Islamic Jewish or Christian texts mention Islam?
Why do ancient Jewish, Roman, and early Christian historians completely ignore any concept of Muhammad or Islamic teaching?
Examples:
The Dead Sea Scrolls contain extensive Jewish theology from before Christ — no hint of Islam.
Josephus (1st-century Jewish historian) writes about Moses, the Law, and Jesus — no Islam.
Church Fathers (2nd–4th centuries) battled heresies for centuries — none ever mentioned Islam.
It’s as if Islam didn’t exist at all before the 7th century.
Because it didn’t.
🚨 Part 5: Why This Destroys the Islamic Narrative
Islam depends on the claim of a single, continuous religion passed down from Adam to Muhammad — unchanged.
But what we actually see is:
Judaism developing through Moses and the covenant with Israel.
Christianity arising from the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.
Islam appearing 600 years later, claiming to correct both — but offering a version of history with no evidence.
If Abraham, Moses, and Jesus were really “Muslims”:
Their messages should look like Islam.
Their followers should have practiced Islam.
Their Scriptures should align with Islamic beliefs.
But none of that is true.
🤯 The Result:
To make Islam “fit,” Muslims must:
Accuse all prior scriptures of corruption — despite the Qur’an affirming them.
Accuse billions of Jews and Christians of misunderstanding their own prophets.
Ignore all historical and archaeological evidence to the contrary.
That’s not truth.
That’s revisionism.
❓Final Questions Every Muslim Must Answer
Where is the evidence that Abraham, Moses, or Jesus practiced or taught Islam?
Why does their actual teaching look 100% non-Islamic?
If their religions were “corrupted,” when did this happen — and where’s the proof?
Why does the Qur’an affirm their scriptures — if they’re supposedly false?
Why does Islam only appear in history after the 7th century?
⚖️ Final Verdict
You can’t rewrite the past to fix a theological problem.
Abraham was not a Muslim.
Moses taught Judaism, not Islam.
Jesus was worshipped as divine, not merely a prophet.
If Islam were true, their lives and teachings would match it.
But they don’t.
Which leads to only one conclusion:
Islam did not restore the original religion.
It invented a new one — then claimed ownership of the past.
And the historical record exposes the contradiction.
No comments:
Post a Comment